Paris, 23 May 2011

Euclidean geometry makes it possible to describe space using planes, spheres, straight lines, points, etc. Can “geometric intuitions” emerge in all human beings, even in the absence of geometric training? To answer this question, the team of cognitive science researchers elaborated two experiments aimed at evaluating geometric performance, whatever the level of education. The first test consisted in answering questions on the abstract properties of straight lines, in particular their infinite character and their parallelism properties. The second test involved completing a triangle by indicating the position of its apex as well as the angle at this apex.

To carry out this study correctly, it was necessary to have participants that had never studied geometry at school, the objective being to compare their ability in these tests with others who had received training in this discipline. The researchers focused their study on Mundurucu Indians, living in an isolated part of the Amazon Basin: 22 adults and 8 children aged between 7 and 13. Some of the participants had never attended school, while others had been to school for several years, but none had received any training in geometry. In order to introduce geometry to the Mundurucu participants, the scientists asked them to imagine two worlds, one flat (“plane”) and the second round (“sphere”), on which were dotted villages (corresponding to the “points” in Euclidean geometry) and paths (”straight lines”). They then asked them a series of questions illustrated by geometric figures displayed on a computer screen. Around thirty adults and children from France and the United States, who, unlike the Mundurucu, had studied geometry at school, were also subjected to the same tests.

The result was that the Mundurucu Indians proved to be fully capable of resolving geometric problems, particularly in terms of planar geometry. For example, to the question “Can two paths never cross?”, a very large majority answered “Yes”. Their responses to the second test, that of the triangle, highlight the “intuitive” character of an essential property in planar geometry, namely the fact that the sum of the angles of the apexes of a triangle is constant (equal to 180°). And, in a spherical universe, it turns out that the Amazonian Indians gave better answers than the French or North American participants who, by virtue of learning geometry at school, acquire greater familiarity with planar geometry than with spherical geometry. Another interesting finding was that young North American children between 5 and 6 years old (who had not yet been taught geometry at school) had mixed test results, which could signify that a grasp of geometric notions is acquired from the age of 6-7 years.

The researchers thus suggest that all human beings have an ability to understand Euclidean geometry, whatever their culture or level of education. People who have received no, or little, training could thus grasp notions of geometry such as points and parallel lines. These intuitions could be innate (they may then emerge from a certain age, as it happens 6-7 years). If, on the other hand, these intuitions derive from learning (between birth and 6-7 years of age), they must be based on experiences common to all human beings.

© Pierre Pica / CNRS

A Mundurucu participant measuring an angle using a goniometer laid on a table.

(1) The two CNRS researchers involved in this study are Véronique Izard of the Laboratoire Psychologie de la Perception (CNRS / Université Paris Descartes) and Pierre Pica of the Unité “Structures Formelles du Langage” (CNRS / Université Paris 8). They conducted it in collaboration with Stanislas Dehaene, professor at the Collège de France and director of the Unité de Neuroimagerie Cognitive à NeuroSpin (Inserm / CEA / Université Paris-Sud 11) and Elizabeth Spelke, professor at Harvard University.

Flexible intuitions of Euclidean geometry in an Amazonian indigene group. Véronique Izard, Pierre Pica, Elizabeth S. Spelke, and Stanislas Dehaene. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, w/c 23 May 2011.

Researcher

Véronique Izard

T +33 (0)1 42 86 21 97 l veronique.izard@m4x.org

Pierre Pica

T +33 (0)1 43 36 49 65 l pierre.pica@orange.fr

CNRS press officer

Priscilla Dacher

T +33 (0)1 44 96 46 06 l priscilla.dacher@cnrs-dir.fr

**Latest press releases**

All disciplines

**9 October 2015**

Designing better catalysts more rapidly**30 September 2015**

New electrode gives micro-supercapacitor macro storage capacity**28 September 2015**

Mimicry helps sheep solve a dilemma**23 September 2015**

A scenario that reconciles the Earth with its origins**23 September 2015**

Biologist Eric Karsenti is awarded the 2015 CNRS Gold Medal**22 September 2015**

Decision-making involves a little known brain region**17 September 2015**

First-ever in vitro human spermatogenesis**9 September 2015**

'Hot Jupiter' exoplanets may have formed very rapidly